Related Clues:

• Past the freshness date
• Past its prime
• No longer new or interesting
• Overused, as expressions
• Played-out
• Contemptibly familiar
• Like several-days-old bread
• Too hard, as bread
• Flat, like beer
• Not real fresh
• Like unfunny jokes
• Like rock-hard bread
• Told and retold, perhaps
• Like a day-old baguette
• Like uncirculated air