Related Clues:

• Almost too coincidental
• Fear-inspiring
• ''___, Indiana'' (TV program)
• Poe-ish
• Weird and scary
• Spinetingling
• Shudder-inducing
• Inducing goosebumps
• Like many John Carpenter films
• Goosebumps-evoking
• Unnerving
• Evoking goose bumps, say
• Like calm, sometimes
• Creeptastic
• Amazingly coincidental