Possible Clues:

• Savage Garden "___ I Loved You"
• 'No surprise to me'
• "Nothing gets past me"
• '___ you were going to say that'
• 'This came as no surprise'
• 'You didn't fool me!'
• 'You didn't fool me'
• "This came as no surprise"
• Response to an unrevealing revelation
• ''No surprise to me''